There is a recent debate on whether sustainable investing necesarily impact portfolio performance negatively. We model the financial impact of portfolio constraints by attributing the performance of dynamic portfolios to contributions from individual constraints. We consider a mean-variance portfolio problem with unknown asset returns. Investors impose a dynamic constraint based on a firm characteristic that contains information about returns, such as the environmental, social, and governance (ESG) score. We characterize the optimal investment strategy through two stochastic Riccati equations. Using this framework, we demonstrate that, depending on the correlation between returns and firm characteristics, incorporating the constraint can, in certain cases, enhance portfolio performance compared to a passive benchmark that disregards the information embedded in these constraints. Our results shed light on the role of implicit information contained in constraints in determining the performance of a constrained portfolio.

This project is joint work with Ruixun Zhang (Peking University), Yufei Zhang (Imperial College London) and Xunyu Zhou (Columbia University).